What these ashes wanted
by Philip
Hoffman
TEXT ON
SCREEN (White on Black)
What these
ashes wanted, I felt sure,
was not
containment but participation.
Not an enclosure of memory,
but the
world. ‑ Mark Doty
HOME MOVIE
(COLOR) OF A WOMAN (M) AND MAN (P) AT A SCHOOLHOUSE...PLAYING IT UP TO THE
CAMERA IN HOME MOVIE STYLE
TEXT ON
SCREEN (white on black):
What these
ashes wanted
MAN’S HANDS
(P) ATTEMPTING TO PUT BROKEN POTTERY BACK TOGETHER - CUT VERY RAPIDLY (COLOR)
HOME MOVIE
(SLOWED DOWN) OF A WOMAN (M) WALKING PAST COLUMNS IN FRONT OF
SOUND
(TELEPHONE ANSWERING MACHINE):
MIKE: Hi Phil, I found this in a book and thought
you might like to hear it, hear goes...
When I call
up pictures of friends, lost, a terrible ache comes over me, so much so that it
has to go away on its own, there isn't much by way of
remedy that I can do. I remember a letter of Henry James where he said that in
times of great grief it was important to `go through the motions of life'; and
then eventually they would become real again.... I've been trying to write
myself a poem about those ancient Japanese ceramic cups, rustic in appearance,
the property at some point of a holy monk, one of the few possessions he
allowed himself. In a later century someone dropped and broke the cup, but it
was too precious simply to throw away. So it was repaired not with glue but
with a seam of gold solder. And I think our poems are often like that gold
solder, repairing the break in what can never be restored perfectly. The gold
repair adds a kind of beauty to the cup, making visible part of its history....
(Taken from a portion of a letter from the poet Alfred Corn, Feb 19,
1994 ‑ from Heaven's Coast by Mark Doty.)
Ok I guess
that’s it ...see you later...
VISITING NURSE
(M) ON DAILY CALLS, SHOT FROM BACK SEAT OF CAR BY (P).
M- It's almost as if I'm experiencing the stress of the contradiction. A stranger going into someone's home, touching their bodies and you don't know what their name is. Going into your private part of your life experiences but you're body is public property and it's being treated by the medical profession. That to me is very strange. 253, Christ… (LOOKING FOR HOUSE ADDRESS).
M LEAVES CAR. DOG WALKS ACROSS ROAD. BOY `DIRECTS’ CONCERT ON FRONT PORCH. M RETURNS. DRIVING CONTINUES.
M- You can't even go to the bathroom there's just so much junk around. I go into the bathroom, and there’s a pair of poopy underwear soaking in the sink . Where am I going to wash my hands? I kind of run my fingers under the tap and wet them.
M- A camera isn't human but it performs the same kind of act…. except it's not working on my physical experience, but on my psychological experience.
P- it’s working on my physical experience.
M LEAVES CAR. M COMES BACK. DRIVING CONTINUES.
M- 57, 57, 74… 57. Bingo. Okay, see you in a minute….bye…(SHE GESTURES AT P BEHIND CAMERA) …Philip kiss me (laugh).
M LEAVES CAR. M RETURNS TO CAR
M- It's really hard for me to do this. I feel like I have to entertain you. That's not what I really mean to say.
P- It's forcing you.
M- I feel like I 'm not really talking about things that I'd want to talk about, things that I'd want to talk about with you.
P- Yeah, because you are talking to the camera.
M- Yeah.
P- Well, it's hard for me, too.
M- Maybe, we should have somebody filming us. Someone
filming you filming me. Why is it hard for you?
P- It’s hard.
M- Because it’s heavy!
P- Yeah.
M- Oh, Philip, here I am talking about psychological difficulties and you're talking about physical ones. You're nuts, you really are nuts. Sometimes I think you are so insensitive, honestly.
P- What I'm saying is I'm concentrating on this which makes me not able to concentrate on what you’re saying or interact…
M- That's a little different than saying that it's hard for me because the camera is heavy. It's a little different, you know? Do you understand the difference?
M LIGHTS UP A SMOKE AND STARES OUT THE FRONT WINDOW
TEXT ON
SCREEN (White on Black):
He always thought they would grow old together
DISSOLVE TO
PHOTO OF
SEASCAPE SEEN FROM A
TEXT ON
SCREEN - (black text superimposed on photo seascape):
I found this photograph
which she took 8 years ago
it was in her desk
paperclipped behind this text:
TEXT ON
SCREEN - SUPERIMPOSED BELOW CAVE OPENING (white on black):
For the
last year I have had this picture hanging before me as I sit at my
desk. It
has plagued me with its possible meanings.
I was convinced that
this
image held and contained meanings and
that if I stared long enough,
they
would tell me something about events around the time of the picture's
taking. I took this picture on September 24, 1988, in
Guadalest,
a small village located 60 miles inland from
here now
I hold my breath in fear of reawakening a bodily memory of that
time. It
was a time when I had begun to relax after a period of intense work.
Simultaneously,
the symptoms I was about to experience over the next ten
Months
began to appear acutely. I began to become intensely aware of how
little
control we have over our body and its functions, of how frightening it
is not to
know. I came to experience, once again, the terror -
of not being
believed
and hence, not being able to believe myself. There were many months
of
darkness and denial until I began to believe myself, to listen and recognise
that
something
extraordinary was taking place in my body.
I have since retraced the
lessons
that taught me the power of naming - more evidence of the logocentric
universe
we inhabit - and the disadvantage of not being able to
describe what is
taking
place in my own world, in my own body.
Two days
ago I awoke, realising that the picture of Guadalest
represented the start of
an inner process.
This process taught
me how to begin to interpret the
world
from the inside out. I see this image as a record of the affective states
of that
time, of the confusion, the desire to hide,
as well as a glimpse at a
phenomenal
process, that I will attempt to expand through my writing.
CAVE IMAGE
CONTINUES
TEXT ON
SCREEN - (black text superimposed on photo seascape):
I do not know much about
the actual place where the photo was taken
but that its taking coincided with a severe illness
which we thought she recovered from.
In a state of wellness which marked her last
years
she travelled and purged the things she felt
created her illness in the first place.
Lodged somewhere in this darkened surround
lays her afterimage.
If I could brighten up this part of the picture
I might illuminate
the conditions of her death
the mystery of her life
and the reasons why
at the instant of her passage
I felt content with her leaving
a feeling I no longer hold.
M AND P
WALKING IN THE SNOW...KISS
(COLOR)
HI-CON
B&W AND HANDPROCESSED IMAGES
SOUND:
MUSIC/SOUNDSCAPE, TELEPHONE MESSAGES DESCRIBING FLOW OF A LIFE:
…and thanks……if you could get in touch with us, and
just wondering how you fellas are getting on, haven’t heard from you in some time, bye for now
its not far out of reach at all….this number is…
This is the culture Lab at Toronto General confirming your appointment for Monday, January 23 at 10:10. If you are unable to attend, please call 310 404-0216… Please remember to bring your Hospital Health Card. Thank-you
…I can offer an alternative situation. If you would like to ring Betty Litkey…. Betty and I've worked together in this office, and she'd be able to give you answers to your questions. Thank you so much, good-bye. The time is ten o-clock…in the morning, I’ll try to get you by 1 o’clock this afternoon, and I’ll try again before five.
…Parallelogram, Students Against Censorship, This Ain’t The Rosedale Library, if you could please call me that would be excellent… Just calling to say hi and whether you want to put up posters before the meeting, or…anyway
Okay, see you. Hope you had a good day, bye….
Yeah, Arrow does a little nervous yawn during that, when you give your message… that’s quite nice…Anyway, It's four o'clock, I'm going into class.
Honey I love you, bye.
Marian. I'm thinking about our paper here alot, and I'm…one of the things we didn't talk about was… schooling as a site of depravation. Would you mind calling me? Bye.
…looks like you got did rid of the fire alarm…and what are we thinking about…
I was wondering if you come and stay with me, sleep over.
Good-bye, love ya….I survived last Wednesday….tried to phone you, um…
Marian…
thank you, can you come in Friday? 10 am tomorrow. That’s Friday…
…your application seems to have gone awry, I tried to call you at half past ten this morning, don’t know whether your bringing it back or whether… I’ve been trying to get a hold of your lawyer, he’s not there. He’s in Palmerston, so I don't know if you set up anything with him….I’m at the office… here in Flesherton… I’ve been across to Mt Forest and the offer is now with the vendors, so I'll get in touch with you tomorrow and let you know how it goes.
I got your name and want to organize some kind of benefit for Danica House, if you could give me a call back, I would really appreciate that.
Hello? Hello, hello this is Denise…Oh hi, hi Denise
I'm calling to say your drum is ready…Hi….
I felt like I… I hung on to your stone very tightly. ..Oh, good.
I felt like I… I talked to my mother in ways that I wanted to….
It’s Saturday night and I just remembered that you said
you’d be in
…my blood test is back, so give me a call, bye…ok. Love you both, bye now, happy new year.
The short message is…it’s a girl! Talk to you later
…Done…we’re $84.00 over-budget that’s about … the bill is five hundred…
…calling from
I wondered if you got my letter….thought you’d be able to do the changes in time for this issue? Just wondering how you're getting on?
Mr. Hoffman?
He's not here, can I take a message?
Is this Mrs. or…?
No, there is no Mrs. Hoffman.
Are you a daughter or….
Hi, it's me, um
Phil…Phil…it’s a girl …we’re so happy…
..whatever is convenient. take care, bye, bye
I love you, bye
I got your card from
had a great time … come to your place… I want to talk to you, I’d love…
Friday
I should be passing through
What are you doing tomorrow night? I thought I’d make dinner
…Is acceptable… well, it has been widely unacceptable in the academy
…I might go…I wanted to speak with you about the proposal.
we haven't got any wood …. you know…
what happened….
yeah… well, my mother…..
it's me again
drive me to the show
I don't know what else to say…but I want to you to be home
…okay, hope you had a good day, bye, bye
COLOR IMAGES IN GARDEN AND AROUND STONE HOUSE
Hello. Will you please call Wilma Rouse at 323-3429. I still have a blouse here that I don’t know what to do with. Thank you.
…Oh, Good…Its hard to…. Its really hard to…Its about 3:34, and um…
Are you there? I was wondering where you were? It’s me…
I won a competition…and
I don’t know where you’re going to be. Anyway, I’ll call you
… Here’s a very short message from a really long way away…. I just called to say that I miss you, and I wanted to hear your voice, but I didn’t hear much of it… ok, bye.
I’ll call again… I’ll talk to you later on tonight. I think I’ll call you later tonight, ok? Bye.
I don’t know what else to say?
…but I want you to be home.
I hope you’re well…
I keep trying to get a hold…
I was wondering where you were?
How did it go?
It went, it went well.
Yeah?
…Or give me a call before…. I’m making dinner.
People said things to one another…like they hadn’t done before…
….I just called to say thanks for the weekend…..
…a nice tropical island….
LADYBUG
MOVES SLOWLY ACROSS LEAF OF PLANT
IN SLOW
MOTION (B&W HI-CON FILM) WOMAN (M) DANCES PLAYFULLY... OFF IN THE DISTANCE
SPINNING AND LAUGHING DISSIPATING INTO THE SNOW... CLEAR WHITE SCREEN…DUST
LADYBUGS
CRAWL AROUND HEART-SHAPED PENDANT, AND STONES.
CHILD’S
HANDS MAKE SHADOWPLAY IN WARM MORNING LIGHT
YOUNG GIRLS
TALK:
m-we have
all different kinds…one we found was black with yellow spots…
j-last
summer were there as much ladybugs as those flies…
m-they were
crawling all over the window sills…
j-and I
accidentally killed it…
m-they’re
all flipped over right now…
SILOUETTE
OF M ON HOSPITAL CURTAIN
M- ...if
you could have a ritual for death what would it be...and would it be private or
shared.
P-...I
think it would be shared
CAMERA
TILTS TO MARIAN’S EYES...THEN TO THE LIGHT
TEXT ON SCREEN
(white on black):
Four
Shadows
FAST MOVING IMAGES FROM
P- Ladybugs.
They hung together like bees on honeycomb, attached to the ceiling in the
hallway adjoining your room. Eventually the spread themselves through every
corner of the house, as if trying to replace your presence…. I followed them
closely.
FAST MOVING
IMAGES AND SOUNDSCAPE CONTINUES
M- (faintly) I dreamt that…I dreamt that we
decided to go back to Canada…and when I came back everything had changed, but
it was still familiar…mostly I remember walking through the snow with you Phil…
FAST MOVING
IMAGES AND SOUNDSCAPE CONTINUES
M-
(faintly) there’s no way any of these hotel employees would ask us what we are
doing because it looks like we belong…..I’m not sure how to figure all this
out…..
P- Not long
before you died, death scenes crept into my life. We watched a course of events
that cast me as witness, each encounter making death less strange. I wondered
why this was happening.
P- This is
the footage we shot in the
She films
the broken bodies strewn on the ground, and the scratched out figure of Queen Hatchepsut,
the female Pharaoh who reigned for more than 20 years. We listen to the tour
guide’s version of history: Theology dictated that in order for the spirit or
soul to live forever, the body, the image, or at least the name of the deceased
must survive on earth. After Hatchepsut’s death a
campaign was mounted against this unconventional female king whereby her name
and image
were defiled, and she was physically removed from the Pharaoh lists, written
out of Egyptian history. In the 19th century with the decipherment of
hieroglyphics pieces of her story gradually came to light and her memory was
reconstituted, but her body had been removed in antiquity and her royal tomb
lays empty to this day.
M TALKS TO CAMERA IN FRONT OF PALM TREES
M-I don't really want to say anything while you're recording. Are you testing it out now. There is no way that any of these hotel employees would come and ask us what we were doing here because we look like we belong, sort of.
P-Why?
M-Well, because we're white, because we have blue eyes, because we dress the way we are. Because we just look entitled in some ways. I'm not sure how to figure this out. It doesn't fit into the categories I have to understand money and wealth and things like that. It's just confusing.
M IS IN
FRONT OF QUEEN HATCHEPSUT’S
P-By late
afternoon on this, the first day of filming, the zoom barrel on the camera
jammed. By early evening the trigger seized up and the camera became non‑operative.
Upon
returning home I was anxious to see how the footage we shot in
FARM BUILDINGS.
MUSEUM OF MOVING IMAGES.
P- I spent
about 2 hours shooting this footage in the
STILL PHOTOS OF
CHILD’S
FINGERS AND LIGHT CARESS CRAWLING LADYBUGS
FAST MOVING IMAGES.
P-Sami and I hurried to catch the 8am train to
As the attendant made his way down the aisle
to stop the train from leaving and call an ambulance, gears engaged and we
slowly pulled away from the
SNOW SCENES. M AND P ON A WINTER WALK. SHADOWS
IN THE SNOW.
KIDS SKATING IN SUNSHINE.
SOUNDSCAPE ENDS.
BLACK
SCREEN
NURSE
REPORT (audio): The lung biopsy itself can lead to some collapse of the
lung...this is often seen after these types of procedures, and the person is
short of breath for awhile, but this does tend to resolve after a few days or
so…
BREAKING
WAVE IN SUPER-SLOW MOTION
TEXT
SUPERIMPOSED ON WAVE:
antiseptic
fictions
invade
the living room
every
story is ours
MUSIC: One is the loneliest number that you ever
have. Two can be as bad as one it’s the loneliest number since the number
one…..
` BAYWATCH’ SOAP OPERA. MAN WAITS BY WOMAN, SLEEPING IN HOSPITAL BED. HE KISSES HER. MAN CARRIES WOMAN
TO BEACH.
NURSE
REPORT (audio over above images): We know that the disease was extensive on
x-rays as well as on the biopsy that they did…they also did echo-cardiogram. Which showed that there was fluid around the chest….around the
heart area as well. Our assumption tonight is that this may have
re-accumulated. We did draw back some fluid from the pericardia area. Now the
echo-cardiogram showed that she did have some dysfunction of the right side of
her heart and this may have been secondary to the ongoing lung problems that
she was having. Over the past couple of days it seemed that she was having more
and more shortness of breath….a couple reasons……
MUSIC ENDS
TEXT ON
SCREEN (white on black):
17
STILL PHOTO
OF GRAMPA IN CASKET
P-Grampa died when I was in the midst of making my 1st film.
As the family photographer I was asked to photograph him in the casket. I
arrived before the grievers, my uncle greeted me and
showed me into the room. It was as if I was on an industrial photo assignment
to film living rooms or something. When I saw him he really didn’t look like
himself yet I knew that what I was doing was important for some of the family.
I took 6 shots and left. So shocked with what I had done, I put the film into
the freezer and left it there for almost a decade. I often wondered why my
uncle never asked me for the photographs, as if the act of organizing the
filming was all that was necessary. Years later I developed the film.
P-(softly)
…17’s the number…1 + 7 is
8 …7 is doing, 8 is infinity…17’s the number….she was born on May
17 and died on November 17…(continues faintly under following narration)
P- My first
encounter with death happened when I was 8. We visited Grampa’s
brother, uncle Hans. He was my Godfather and I remember him from the smoke
filled card games Grampa had in the rec-room where wine flowed like water and German music
blared amidst the hollering. Uncle Hans had lung cancer, I was told, because he
smoked. Mom took us up to the hospital and with sunshine streaming in I heard
for the first time the death gargle.
P-(softly)…my
dad was born April 17, my uncle was born on April 17 and my grandfather was
born on April 17……my sisters were born on June 17…..1 is 1…7 is for doing and 8
is infinity…my seat on the plane was 17…(continues)
P- Aunt
Katie was the widow of Uncle Hans. Every Christmas I would visit her, 1st with
mom, and later on my own. She spoke little English and I spoke little German
but we spoke. She was happy that I was working in film and television: ` Just
the other day the TV repair man charged her a bundle for only a short visit’,
so she was assured that I had chosen a lucrative career. On my last visit she
complained about a nagging backache, and whispered to herself `time goes’, over and over `time
goes’....A call came from my uncle in the summer, asking if I could help move
Aunt Katie’s things. When I asked if she was moving he told me that she had
died 3 months ago.
P-(softly)
My sisters were born on June 17th, in 1953…after spreading her ashes
in England, Finland and Spain, my seat number was 18… my dad was born April 17,
my uncle was born on April 17 and my grandfather was born on April
17…(continues)
P- My
mother carried her first pregnancy 9 months but the foetus was born dead. Apparently the doctor new that the foetus was not living weeks
before the delivery, but they didn’t want to upset my mother with this terrible
news. My parents had already
named him Phillip after my father and grandfather. They buried him at the family
plot but the priest refused to partake in the ceremony and bless the grave
claiming that the foetus was born dead, and therefore the spirit had already
left for limbo. My father still sites this event as the reason he stopped going
to church on a regular basis. After the triplets were born my mother got
pregnant again and had me. I remember sitting on grampa’s
knee as he proclaimed that Phillip the third would take over the family
business, but I think he really meant Phillip the fourth.
HEALTH CARE
CUTS PROTESTERS IN
(B&W
HI-CON)
RADIO
ANNOUNCER 1 (audio)- …and really that is all of it, because other then protest
areas all the other major routes lighter than usual, in town we are running
accident free. Help change the problems and challenges and headaches of running
a business, into profits. Call AT&T Accounting Systems…
RADIO
ANNOUNCER 2 (audio)-
We’re just at elm Street now where a group of probably several hundred
Health Care Workers are protesting outside of he
M IN FRONT OF DESK, IN STUDY. CAMERA
MOVES TO WINDOW. (B&W)
P- autumn came this year in strange colours
your
breath was short
a cough
persisted through November
what used
to go away didn't
cancer
STILL PHOTO OF HANDS. FOOD. (B&W)
a word
that stayed carefully off
your list
of possible causes
cancer
arose out
of your 3 hour a night sleeps
when the
doctor said it might be cancer
and you
should prepare yourself for surgery
you asked
me to take you to the beach
TEXT ON
SCREEN (white on black):
The sadness
comes and goes
like when
there are fast moving clouds
covering
and uncovering the sun
as it
makes its way across the sky
P- your coat covers the strapped‑in cardiograph machine
we sneak
out of the hospital into the night
a dome of
clouds circled above
the water
was black and rippling
STILL PHOTO
OF BEACH AT NIGHT (B&W)
P- you skipped a stone
and I
took this picture
STILL
PHOTOS, HOSPITAL (B&W)
DOCTOR
(faintly)- she’s in the recovery room…..all the
changes in her lungs
are
cancerous….it appears….
STILL
PHOTOS OF SANTA CLAUS PARADE (B&W)
P- On the
third day after the operation
your
breathing got worst
We watched
your decline
as the
Santa Claus parade
marched
by your window
A-
He
wanted to know what we expected, and I that they find out what was wrong,
because
there was no explanation of why she was deteriorating. I really don’t remember
what I said but he said there’s 70 patients on this
floor that we are responsible for….
MOVING
SLOWLY PAST HOSPITAL (B&W)
PROTEST
MARCH (B&W)
A-
I
felt that the nurses were there..I
felt that they were very good at co-operating around her care. I think Marian
was relieved to have it over and, very connected with people.
FARMHOUSE
HALLWAY, SUNLIGHT DISSIPATES (pixillation)
A-
Letting
herself just be cared for, so Philomene started to
rub her feet with lotion and she just said it felt so good..and she washed her face with a hot wash cloth and
she just loved…..
CLOSEUP OF HANDS PACKING AWAY HER BELONGINGS.
MANY
LADYBUGS CRAWLING ON WINDOW
TEXT ON
SCREEN (black text supered over window):
the night we had our last walk
she wrote these words
TEXT ON
SCREEN (white on black):
We come
together ‑ separate
cry and
look wide‑eyed bewildered ...
I want to
be near the water
We bundle
up and leave the hospital for the beach
Beautiful
clear crisp blue skied night
we mourn
together
laughing
at intervals
clinging
madly to some sense of life
The open
sky ‑ water makes me feel
part of
something immeasurable
larger
than me
and it is
consoling
STILL
PHOTOS OF M’S ROOM: BAGS, LILIES, WRITING, FAMILY PHOTOS,
DESK, CD
(P.J. HARVEY), PHOTO OF M’S GRANDMOTHER
TEXT ON
SCREEN (white on black - end credits):
A self to
which it would be
worth her while to be true
Marian
McMahon
May 17, 1954 -
November 17, 1996
assistance in
conceptual development & editing
Anna
Gronau
Philomene Hoffman
Vesa Lehko
Janine
Marchessault
music composed & performmed
by
Tucker
Zimmerman
sound mix by
Tim Muirhead & Teresa Morrow
titles & assistance in optical
printing
Marcos
Arriaga
assistant picture editing
Eric
Yu
kind assistance along the way
Belinda
Budge
Lisa
Freeman
Marg Gorrie
Mike
Hoolboom
Gary
Popovich
Amy Rossiter
Karyn Sandlos
Roberto
Ariganello
Mike
Cartmell
Ryan
Feldman
Joohyun Kwon
Sarah
Lightbody
Brenda
Longfellow
Susan
Lord
Wayne
Salazar
Rick
Hancox
Colleen
Hoffman
Frannie Hoffman
Sue
and Phil Hoffman
Graham
Jackson
McMahon
Family
Jeffrey
Paull
Leena Louhivuori
Mikko Maasalo
Ilppo Pohjola
Perttu Rastas
Seppo Renvall
Juha Samola
Sami van Ingen
Denise
Ziegler
institutional support
Graduate
Programme in
Film
& Video,
Media
Arts Department
Liaison
of Independent Filmmakers
of
produced with the assistance of
The
Philip Hoffman 2001